Wednesday, August 5, 2009

Switchfoot


A week ago today we were driving back from Salt Lake City, after having seen Switchfoot once again in concert, this time at the Saltaire Pavilion. Was it worth driving five hours one way through triple-digit temperatures, only to get lost at one point and almost miss it? Absolutely, it was. There were only a few hundred people there at most, and it was great to get up (fairly) close to the stage. I was the old guy wearing the red "i like switchfoot" T-shirt, by the way. On the return trip, I got to thinking about why this particular band has meant so much to me (especially in light of the fact that I'm quickly approaching the half-century mark, as my youngest son constantly reminds me). It's not easy to explain.

When Switchfoot first released "Chem 6A," it just resonated with me like very few songs ever have. The music is incredible (if you've listened to any of their albums, you already know that), but there was something more. The lyrics portray this tension between the ideal and the real - in this case, someone who seems to be settling for the artificial world of entertainment as a substitute for a life that is more genuine but may be harder to attain. Or something like that. I was the student dean of a Bible college at the time, and some of us went to see them when they were part of a line-up that included All-Star United and a couple of other bands. The concert was at a church on the corner of Cloverdale and Fairview, as I recall. Afterwards, I remember writing an article in the student newspaper about the band just because they had made such a huge impression on me.

The other concerts we've been to were held at the Big Easy in downtown Boise (renamed the Knitting Factory, for some bizarre reason). Without a doubt, they have been among the best shows I've ever had the privilege to experience. Let me add, I've been to a lot of concerts over the years: The Stones, The Who, Clapton (multiple times), Dylan, The Police (when tickets cost five bucks), etc., etc. Out of all of them, the comparison I tend to make to Switchfoot is with Bruce Springsteen (believe it or not), right when he was getting big. I draw a parallel not because of musical styles, but because of the energy of his three-hour show back in the early eighties.

We were in the second row that time, and it was obvious that Springsteen was someone who genuinely loved not only making music, but also making a connection with everyone in the audience. That's what every Switchfoot concert I've been to has been like. At the Salt Lake show, Jon actually got off the stage and walked through the crowd in mid-song. The last time they were in Boise, they even brought some kid up on stage to sing along with them. It's like the band sort of makes the barrier between them and the audience disappear.

The other factor has to be the sincerity of their devotion. I remember a quote from an interview Jon gave in the Idaho Statesman. He said something along the lines of: "We're a Christian band by conviction, not merely by musical genre." That has always stuck with me. Again, I don't find it easy to explain why songs like "Meant to Live," "This is Your Life," and "Gone" have been such an inspiration to me, but they just have.

In the last ten years or so (you know you're long in the tooth when you start measuring your life in decades), alternative Christian music (although I'm not real into labels such as that one) has been a catalyst for spiritual transformation and renewal in my life (you might even call it an "awakening"). When I listen to the music that these guys put out, it strikes a chord with me - they're trying to live faithfully in a world that constantly challenges them to do otherwise.

A couple of weeks ago, I had to fill in for our minister and preach a sermon. My chosen text was Ephesians 2:10, my title was "An Unfinished Masterpiece," and I felt like the lyrics from "The Economy of Mercy" was one of the most effective ways I could have found to make the point that God continues to write more lines to the poems of our lives: These carbon shells/These fragile dusty frames/House canvasses of souls/We are bruised and broken masterpieces/But we did not paint ourselves.

I could cite all kinds of other examples to illustrate how these guys have made a huge difference to me, but maybe the best is from my current favorite song, "Burn Out Bright":

If we only got one try
If we only got one life
If time was never on our side
Before I die I want to burn out bright

That's what I'm trying to say.

Saturday, July 11, 2009

Religulous


I’ll admit it; Bill Maher is a funny guy. And by taking aim at religion, he’s got more than enough easy targets to hit in his film Religulous. For more than just laughs, Maher attacks the very characters I am likewise outraged or embarrassed by, often because of their hypocrisy or stupidity or both. But the very ones I tend to dismiss as fringe elements (a very small minority out of the many for whom religion matters and ought to be taken seriously), Maher takes to be representative of the whole. My objections to Religulous, though, go far beyond who counts as “fringe” and who does not.

Let’s start at the end, rather than the beginning, because that’s when Maher puts all his cards on the table. After lambasting the major western religions, he concludes his film with a passionate appeal to reject religion entirely, because “religion must die for mankind to live.” We read verses from the Qur’an and the Bible superimposed on scenes of bombs exploding. The end is near, apparently, and our only hope is to stamp out faith in all of its forms, bizarre and otherwise. In stark contrast to religious gullibility, Maher claims, “doubt is humble.” And yet, not once in the film do we ever get the impression that Maher doubts his own assessment of the situation, not even for a moment.

Theism: bad; Atheism: good. This is to me a red flag, to put it mildly. I watched Religulous over the Fourth of July weekend. Just a day or so before, I had heard on the news that North Korean leader Kim Jung Il was threatening to conduct a nuclear test, and had missiles already pointed at Honolulu and San Francisco. As a Communist, Jung Il shares Maher’s atheistic viewpoint, but obviously I’m much more concerned about the damage he could do than any harm inflicted by televangelists. So, why does atheism get a pass?

Let’s not forget Joseph Stalin, whose “Great Purge” in the 1930s was responsible for the deaths of at least 3 million (some would estimate the number to be closer to 9 million). Likewise, Pol Pot’s reign of terror in the “killing fields” of Cambodia decimated roughly a third of the population of that country. Could it be that atheism is as dangerous as religion, if not more so? And yet, Maher makes no mention whatsoever of its recent horrors.

Religulous does have its undeniably funny moments, but if Maher want to be taken seriously, it seems odd to me that he devotes the shortest amount of time in his “documentary” to probably the most intelligent interviewee on the entire film: Dr. Francis Collins, head of the Human Genome Project. In fact, Collins later said that most of the good footage from their discussion ended up on the cutting room floor.

Surprising as it may seem, there were definitely points with which I found myself agreeing with Maher. There are problems when the line between church and state becomes blurry, no argument there. History has demonstrated that time and time again. And I also object to people who use religion as a means to get rich, no less so than Maher does.

But Religulous oversteps its bounds, in my opinion, when it attempts to make its case that the Christian story is nothing more than the first-century variation of a Mediterranean myth that had already circulated for an entire millennium. This is when, in my mind, Maher loses any claims to credibility. That, and the way he insist on calling the last book of the Bible Revelations, instead of its proper title, Revelation, of course.

Are there parallels between the death and resurrection of Christ and similar “dying and rising” myths in the ancient world? Certainly. And the best analysis of them I have ever read comes from none other than C.S. Lewis, who is perhaps best remembered as a Christian apologist, but who was also a renowned expert in world mythology. Lewis basically reasons that the theme of rising from the dead is a universal longing within the human heart, and we would expect to see glimpses of it among the stories that various cultures have told to themselves. You can read more about it in a lecture I wrote for my mythology course:

http://www.commutercampus.com/mythology/powerofmythcritique.html

Maher contends that the Egyptian deity Horus was crucified and resurrected, and thus his story was identical to that of the Christian Gospels, only a thousand years earlier. What escapes the notice of the filmmakers is that these claims are easy to make but very difficult to prove. Let me suggest a starting place: crucifixion was unknown to the ancient Egyptians. In fact, it is this same historical fact that has led many to question the historicity of another religious text, the Qur’an, because the Muslim book makes reference to crucifixions in Egypt as well. There is no evidence that executions ever took place there in such a way at that time.

My favorite scene in Religulous was when Bill Maher stopped in at a “trucker’s chapel.” There he met a few truck drivers who weren’t quite sure what to make of his claims that the Bible was full of contradictions. I guess what I appreciated was how, even though they didn’t know the answers, they didn’t pretend that they did. They made a circle around Maher and prayed for him. Maher told them thanks for "being Christ-like, and not just Christian." There often can be a big difference between the two – unfortunately, it is too easy to wear the label “Christian” but to completely neglect “being Christ-like” at the same time.

In spite of all the many flaws of the film, if Religulous is a reminder not only that such hypocrisy exists, but that it has also been the very thing that has caused many (Maher included) to give up on religion entirely, then perhaps it has served a valuable service.

Please note: the image of the film above is included here only as part of a critical film review - if so requested by the copyright owner, it will be immediately removed.

Wednesday, July 1, 2009

A Case of Mistaken Identity


We've had Yukon Cornelius for almost two years now (whose name needs no explanation to baby boomers, but his namesake was the gruff prospector on the clay-mation classic "Rudolph"). All this time I've been telling people that he is part Newfoundland, because he is black, hairy and about the size of a small pony. I had to take him to a new vet the other day and, behold, he took one look at him and said he was sure he was Gordon setter.

Notice what the Gordon Setter Club of America has to say about the breed:

"... alert and lively, pleasant and exceedingly loyal They tend to be devoted to members of their household." That fits. Apparently, he had no problem identifying the alpha male, and I literally cannot even go to the bathroom without him following me in there. That leaves very little room to maneuver.

"a Gordon would stay a 'puppy' forever" That fits, too.

"They do, however, need plenty of daily exercise to maintain peak physical and mental condition." We figured this one out by his carrying a Frisbee around in his teeth every waking moment and giving me "the look."

"Constant wagging of their tail seems to be part of their style as well" Check.

"Many Gordons are great talkers. They can develop quite a vocabulary with various tones to express themselves." This one is as completely accurate as it is truly bizarre. It's almost as if he is attempting to form words at times. He'll roll around on the floor moaning or chuckling or whatever it is he does. That coupled with the quizzical expressions he gets on his face can be somewhat unnerving.

Case closed. He's a Gordon.

Monday, June 8, 2009

Raining on the Idaho Film Fest

My son and a few of his little friends spent a couple of days last week putting together a 6-minute film. They worked on it 48 hours straight, in fact, as part of the I-48 film fest in Boise. Last year, their team actually won an award, and they had high hopes this time around, but alas, all their hard work was overlooked on Saturday. But it was definitely a good effort in the sci-fi category.

Afterwards, we went out for Mexican food downtown, planning to go see the Boise Burn play arena football later. The weather seemed fine went we went in; not so much while we were leaving. I don't ever remember it raining quite as hard as it did then, and I've lived in Boise almost twenty years now. We were completely soaked, and I mean drenched as if we had taken a 10-minute shower with our clothes on. The football game was over by the time we started to dry out.

In the midst of the downpour, I got to thinking about something Jesus said once about God: "He sends rain on the righteous and the unrighteous" (Matthew 5:45). Maybe this seems like a stretch, then again maybe not, but it occurred to me that there's just no way to tell from outward appearances the difference between the "bad guys" and the "good guys," at least not all the time. We had a discussion in class not long ago about this point as it relates to "cosmic justice." On the one hand, eastern religions often tend to weigh in on cosmic justice in terms of karma and reincarnation. By looking at one lifetime, it may not appear that justice is somehow served: seemingly good people get hurt, and seemingly bad people get away with hurting others. But if the big picture includes multiple lifetimes, then justice is ultimately met because everyone gets exactly what they deserve, nothing more and nothing less, according to this view.

Judaism and Christianity provide a different perspective here. In our class, I mentioned the familiar story of Job, and how, in spite of all his suffering, God never exactly gave him a straight answer as to why he had to go through the ordeal. One way to sum up the story is to say that no answer (for now) is better than the wrong answer. With all due respect to those who embrace reincarnation as a fitting answer to the question of cosmic justice, in my opinion it is too neat and too simple. H.L. Mencken's famous quote may apply here: "For every problem, there is a solution that is simple, elegant...and wrong." As I see it, all Job had been hearing from his friends at the beginning of the book were answers that were "simple" and "elegant." Job had sinned, his friends believed, and therefore he was getting exactly what he deserved. But in the end, God's silence was to be preferred to their wrong answers. "I know that my Redeemer lives," he said (Job 19:25), and even if appearances may seem to totally contradict that belief, trust that God ultimately will bring about justice (but he may not provide easy answers in the meantime) is what matters most.

Saturday, May 23, 2009

Shoshone Falls




A week ago, my youngest son and I went on a short road trip down to Twin Falls to go to a concert. It was great: Red Airplanes, Wavorly, The Wedding, and House of Heroes. I'm glad we went because I loved the music, but it was a long drive, I'll admit. As soon as we got there, I drove a couple of miles down the road to take a look at Shoshone Falls. They said a few weeks ago that it was the strongest water flow in ten years. It had tapered off some, but it was still impressive. It's even higher than Niagra Falls! Niagra Falls...slowly I turn...step by step...inch by inch...






Saturday, May 9, 2009

Reasons for Hope

One of the saddest things I have ever heard in my life was during a funeral yesterday. A nineteen-year-old girl was trying to say goodbye to her father, a man who died very suddenly last week. Choking back tears, she said her dad always treated everyone he met with respect. I know from first-hand experience that this is true. John Hardison always dealt with people that way, even when it was especially difficult in his role as Deputy Chief of Prisons. He will definitely be missed.

Right after the funeral, I found myself answering questions from one of my online religion students. She shall remain anonymous, but given the circumstances yesterday, it seems that what I had to say to her then was very fitting, and I’m grateful to her for giving me the opportunity to consider again what I believe about death, among other things. I’ll repeat most of it here, for whatever it’s worth.

Not being disrespectful...With the sampler platter of religions you have tried, how do you know your current one is correct? How does your conviction of your religion being the "one" differ from the conviction of the Muslim or Sciencetology?

I really do appreciate your asking questions, and you are not being disrespectful in the least. I’ll do my best to answer them.

The short answer is that to this day, I still have never come across any other religious teacher or philosophical system that compares with not only the life and works of Jesus, but also with his death and resurrection. In my opinion, there are very good reasons to believe that the eyewitnesses who wrote Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John actually did record what they saw and heard from Jesus. A metaphor that I use constantly in my classes is: which way do the scales tip? In this case, I believe they tip in favor of the Gospel, and it is reasonable to believe that what Jesus said was true.

Now for the longer answer. The first time I ever picked up a Bible and attempted to read it on my own was when I spent a night in juvenile detention. I would try it again when I was in college, and by then I would be comparing what Jesus had to say with other voices I had listened to (among them, Buddha and the Maharishi). There seems to be no one who would even come close in terms of Jesus’ integrity and compassion. Is it a “leap of faith” to decide that? Sure, but as I see it, it is not a “blind leap” at all; because you first look to see which way the scales are indicating is the most reasonable. During my freshman year, one book that had a profound influence on me was Mere Christianity by C.S. Lewis. While majoring in comparative religion in the years that followed, I never encountered anyone or any system that effectively refuted the conclusion I had reached, although I should stress that I earnestly searched in order to challenge my own beliefs. I did that then and I still do it now.

There are many criteria that must be met, in my opinion, before a religion or philosophy ought to be personally adopted, but I will just mention two. It should not be entirely subjective, and it ought to offer an answer to the mystery of death. In my bio, I mentioned my seeking a sort of “psychedelic enlightenment,” and by that I mean I went the whole nine yards in my search: pot, hash, opium, mushrooms, LSD, the works. I “saw” lots of things, as you might well imagine. I sat on the back step of my friend’s house and I was totally convinced that I had become “one” with a plane flying overhead. But was I? Other relevant questions are: is truth simply whatever I (subjectively) decide it to be? And, is something true just because I say so?

To make a long story somewhat shorter, I think it is more reasonable to conclude that the “world” out there really is “real,” and because of that conclusion, I necessarily have to reject the notion that I had previously embraced within eastern religions that everything ultimately is illusory. The Jewish and Christian view offers a different perspective, one in which God created everything and declared it good.

As to the other criteria, I just attended a funeral for a friend about three hours ago. John, who was not too much older than me, died suddenly of a massive heart attack this week. It was a shock that I am still coming to terms with. Today at the memorial service I heard someone quoting Jesus, who said “I am the resurrection and the life.” It’s a reasonable question to ask, is he really those things? And, why should we believe him when he says so?

Once again, I come back to the eyewitnesses who saw his empty tomb, and I understand that to be a validation of the words he spoke. Jesus offering a solution to the problem of death is crucial. If I can get somewhat personal once more, I’ll add that my brother committed suicide about six months after I became a Christian. I decided it made sense to trust what Jesus had said about himself, even (and maybe especially) when it was most painful.

I already made the point that if I accept one “truth claim” (in this case, that what Jesus said was right), then the necessary implication is that I am at the same time rejecting those competing truth claims that deny it. I hope that makes sense. It simply means I can’t have it both ways. But you ask a great question about other groups that are likewise exclusive. If I had more time, I’d make the case that every religion similarly insists that their way is the one, most accurate and comprehensive way – the claim itself is certainly not unique to Christianity.

To be completely honest, I really do hope to maintain my faith in Jesus without any smugness or superiority or intolerance. For example, accepting Christianity reasonably has to mean rejecting atheism. But does it also mean that a Christian has to resort to violence or intimidation or the illegitimate use of power against atheists to try to force them to accept what he or she believes? Absolutely not. By the way, I really am convinced there is much to learn from other religions and philosophies – I’m finding out new things all the time, and it definitely keeps me humble knowing I have so much to learn.

Sunday, May 3, 2009

Prayer Meeting at the Tool Company

Every Friday morning, I meet with some of the guys for a Bible study over breakfast. Last time my friend Cleve made a suggestion that since a local tool company is facing tough times in this economy, we ought to go over there and pray for them. He was right – prayer helps, and it makes sense to go there and do just that, especially since some of our good friends and fellow believers depend on it to make a living. So we did. A few of us got together in their conference room and spent some time praying that God would continue to bless their tool business.

I have to say it was a welcome reminder of what an elder is supposed to be all about. My favorite description of what an elder in the church is to be is simply a “shepherd.” Elders “tend” the “flock.” Yes, at times, they have to attend meetings, make decisions, and figure out how to spend money. But much higher on the list of priorities, in my opinion, is that elders are supposed to be shepherds. And it felt right to be there in that conference room praying with some of the very people who are most affected by the economic downturn.

Today is a good day to remember, too. It was 29 years ago today that I stood up in the back row of a worship service at a college retreat and interrupted the minister by asking to be baptized. It’s a good day for another reason: my own brother is being acknowledged as an elder in his congregation on this May 3rd as well. Not to mention, Dad would have been 77 on this day, too. My prayer is that we would always bear in mind the things that matter most.